~ Prologue ~

I was born into a military family.
My father flew fighters, and I learned at an early age that some fathers leave in the morning and do not come back, and that the ones who come back do not always talk about it.
I was, I think, seven years old the first time I understood what that meant.
The lesson came because there was a pilot my father flew with who was also one of my father’s best friends. He and his wife had come to our home for dinner more than once, and I remember he had a way of making my mother laugh when they were in the kitchen talking. When we found out he had died, the news hit our family hard.
As I came to understand, he went up on a routine mission with two other pilots, the mission my father had flown a hundred times, and as they changed lead positions, somewhere over the farms that surrounded the air base, something happened and his plane went down.
My father told me almost none of this. I learned it the way children learn things their parents are not ready to explain. I picked up bits and pieces from the changes in the house, the way someone answered the phone, my mother’s expression when she believed no one was observing, and the stories shared at school. What I remember clearly is not the crash but the funeral, and how the bugler’s notes changed everyone there
There were more uniforms than I had ever seen in one place, rows of them, men my father’s age standing very straight and still. My family sat close to the coffin, and as I stood with them, my mother gripped my hand more tightly than necessary while the chaplain spoke to people down the line. I did not grasp most of what the chaplain said, but as the ceremony started, I realized that my father, who I thought was tougher than the rest of us, clenched his jaw and stared into the middle distance in a way I had never seen before.
When the ceremony ended, they folded the American flag into its tight triangle and gave it to our friend’s wife, who sat near us in the front row. I remember her holding on to the flag, and when they finished saying something to her, there was nothing left to say. I thought the funeral was over.
Then, a soldier stepped forward with a bugle and raised it.
He played just twenty-four notes. Twenty-four notes I would never forget.
Since then, I have heard that melody many times, but I have never heard it the way I heard it that afternoon. It was plain: no grand beginning, no singing, no chorus, nothing that made it special. It seemed far too simple to matter, and yet the moment those notes began, everything stopped. The men stopped shifting their weight and stood motionless. My brothers and sisters, who had been fidgeting, went quiet as we watched a field full of strangers and grieving people become, for less than a minute, completely still, some bowing their heads and some weeping.
What was happening then made me look up at my father, maybe for support, but mostly out of curiosity. I saw something on his face and had no words for it, and have spent a good part of my life trying to understand it ever since. He was not crying and was quieter and more attentive than I had ever seen him. He listened to those notes as you listen to a familiar voice, and I understood, without being told, that the notes were conveying to him something he could not express himself. Good-bye.
When the last note faded, no one spoke.
Later I learned the song was called “Taps.” I learned that soldiers always played it as part of the burial ritual. On the drive home, I turned to my father with the questions that had been forming in my mind: Where had the song come from? Who wrote it? Why? And why did soldiers play it at the burial?
He was quiet for a while, then told me he didn’t know. He said it the way he said the few things he admitted he didn’t know, which was rare and, to me, seemed close to regret.

PART ONE

Two Families, One Story

I.

Philadelphia before the war

Philadelphia seemed forever in motion: prosperous, crowded, and noisy, a city of commerce and industry where respectable doorways opened directly onto a changing and complicated world. At the end of the block, beneath a weathered signboard and beside a wide alley smothered in fog, stood the Mackullman workshop, which smelled of sawdust and varnish and fresh-cut pine. Caleb had been sanding the leg of a rocking chair at the bench by the window when something in the parlor made him stop. It was the piano. Three notes, and then two more, and then a pause before the first three came again, only slightly changed—turned, the way a person turns a thing over in the hand to see it from the other side. He knew the pieces Nora was supposed to be practicing, and this was not one of them.
Around him, the workshop went on as it always did. A saw rasped behind the partition; his father’s voice carried low and even through some negotiation with a customer, and from the street came the clatter of wheels over the stones. Caleb heard none of it. He set the sandpaper down and listened to the parlor, where the three notes came a fourth time, patient and deliberate, and then broke off.
“Nora?” he called.
The music stopped and a moment later there was only the silence of a child caught at something, and then one soft note, struck as if by accident, drifted back to him. He smiled and went to find her.
She was sitting on the piano bench with her feet nowhere near the floor, five years old and small enough that she had to lean forward to reach some keys. She had tied back her dark hair that morning, though by now several strands had worked loose and hung about her face, and a sheet of paper lay beside her on the bench.
“What are you playing?”
“Nothing.”
“I heard you.”
“I was just trying it.”
“Trying what?”
Nora did not answer. Instead, she played the three notes again.
Caleb came closer. “That sounds different.”
“I made it.”
He looked at her. “You made it?”
She nodded.
“All of it?”
“Most of it.”
Caleb picked up the paper. Marks covered the page—some resembling musical notes, others nothing more than circles, lines, and shapes he could not understand. At the bottom, Nora had drawn something that looked vaguely like a flower.
“What is this?”
“My song.”
“Does it have a name?”
“No.”
“Every song needs a name.”
“Why?”
“So you know what it is.”
She thought about that quickly.
“It’s Caleb.”
He laughed. “You named it Caleb?”
She nodded.
“Then I suppose it has a name.”
He looked again at the page. Caleb understood enough about music to recognize what she had been attempting. The notes wandered across the paper. Some were too large, some were upside down, and others were nowhere near where they ought to have been.
He pointed to a group of them. “This doesn’t work.”
Nora’s expression changed.
“What doesn’t?”
“This.” He tapped the paper. “You can’t put that there.
“Why?”
“Because it doesn’t belong there.”
“Yes, it does.
“No.”
“It does in my song.”
Caleb looked at her. Nora folded her arms across her chest.
“All right,” he said. “Show me.”
She climbed back onto the bench. “Play it.”
Nora placed her fingers on the keys and played the opening phrase. Then she reached the passage Caleb had objected to and played it exactly as she had written it.
Caleb waited.
The notes were there, but something was wrong. They did not lead where the melody wanted to go.
“It needs to change,” he said.
“How?”
Caleb took the pencil.
“Like this.”
Nora watched as he made a mark beneath the notes.
“You can’t do that.”
“Why?”
“Because that’s not what I wrote.”
“Then write it differently.”
She frowned, then erased one note and replaced it with another.
“Try it.”
Nora played the passage again.
This time Caleb heard it.
There.
A tiny change. Almost nothing. But the melody moved.
Nora looked at him.
“You heard it.”
“Yes.”
“So, it was wrong.”
“No.”
She frowned. “Then why did you make me change it?”
“I said it needed fixing.”
“That means it was wrong.”
Caleb shook his head. “It means the song wasn’t finished.
Nora considered this. Then she smiled.
“Where else?”
Caleb laughed. “What?”
“Where else does it need fixing?”
He pointed to the page.
“There.”
She changed it.
“And there.”
She changed that, too.
They kept working until the paper was covered with pencil marks. Sometimes Caleb was right, sometimes Nora was right, and sometimes neither of them was certain.
Those were the places they liked best.
After a while, Nora played the beginning again.
Caleb reached for a scrap of paper.
“What are you doing?”
“Writing it down.”
“Why?”
“So, you don’t forget it. It’s worth keeping.”
“I won’t forget it.”
“You might.”
“I made it.”
“That doesn’t mean you won’t forget it.”
She gave him a look, then played.
Caleb wrote.
She played the phrase again, and he added another note. Then Nora changed the rhythm, and Caleb crossed something out.
“What are you doing?” she asked.
“Starting over.”
She smiled.
“Listen.”
Caleb put down the pencil.
Nora played the phrase again.
This time he did not look at the keys. He listened. He heard where the melody rose, where it hesitated, and where it seemed ready to settle before moving somewhere else instead.
Nora played it again.
Caleb wrote.
When she finished, he turned the paper toward her.
Nora studied it.
“That doesn’t look like it.”
“It is.”
“No, it isn’t.”
“You haven’t played it yet.”
She sat down.
Caleb placed the paper on the piano.
“Try it.”
Nora played the first note, then the second. She stopped.
Caleb waited.
She played the rest.
When she finished, she looked over her shoulder.
“You wrote it.”
Caleb looked at the page. He did not think it was anything remarkable. All he had done was listen to her playing and write what he heard. Still, he believed it was worth keeping.
Now he looked at the notes again.
“Play it.”
Nora did.
He listened.
There it was—the turn in the melody, the tiny hesitation, and then the change she had made the second time through. Every note was exactly as he had written it.
He had heard all of it.
Not just the tune.
Everything.
“Again,” he said.
Nora laughed. “You sound like Mother.”
Again.”
She played it.
This time Caleb closed his eyes
The piano was still beneath Nora’s fingers, but he could hear the melody somewhere else now—in his own head, separate from the instrument. When she stopped, it was still there
Caleb opened his eyes and looked first at the paper, then at Nora.
He understood something he had never understood before.
She could find music.
He could catch it.
Outside, a wagon rattled past the workshop. Somewhere along the street, a man called out the day’s news. Neither child listened.
Nora placed her hands on the keys again.
“I have another part,” she said.
Caleb picked up his pencil.
“Go on…”
In the years that followed—Nora at the piano finding things, Caleb at his bench catching them—the two of them argued over phrases until neither could remember who had first been right, and both felt that what they had worked on was worth keeping.

Watch Video
About the Story